Canadian philanthropist Pierre Lassonde, a major collector of McNicoll’s work, flew over to London to see the painting in person.
During the show, he said: “For a painting that has been missing for 110 years, I think it’s fantastic… I wouldn’t mind adding one more piece to my collection.”
Mr Taylor described the experience as “an absolute adventure”.
“The [Fake or Fortune?] team and the BBC have made the journey memorable and exciting,” he said.
“I believed in the painting from day one, and I’m hopeful that it could achieve a record price,” he added.
The painting is currently being stored in a gallery and Mr Taylor plans to sell it at auction in the near future.
Listen to highlights from Lincolnshire on BBC Sounds, watch the latest episode of Look North or tell us about a story you think we should be covering here, external.